Abolishing performance ratings not without risk

Published on

Here's some interesting research insight into the perils of abandoning performance ratings.

The thinking tends to be that imposing performance ratings will be counterproductive, reinforce stereotypes, encourage the idea that managers only have to have performance conversations once a year and that the annual performance appraisal system is so time consuming. The obvious answer, abandon it. Hmmm, seems that may not be the answer. Too often, and perhaps not surprisingly, the result is that, instead of encouraging a continuing discussion about performance, no discussion takes place at all or, if it does, the employee does not understand what s/he is being told.

Sadly, the report concludes, most managers are not skilled enough to deliver clear, meaningful messages, without some structure.

Maybe an answer is to keep some structure but also give those managers some training in providing effective feedback - it is, arguably, the most important part of their job after all.

It was the companies who removed ratings and made the review process less formal that ran into trouble. When the process was stripped of all formality, managers just skipped it. Leaving employees in the dark about how they’re doing.

Related Articles

Who would you tell? Finding a workplace ally when something’s not right

In the months following #metoo many employers have done a lot of great work to address potential harassment risk in the workplace - embedding clear poli...

‘I’m a hugger’, badges we give ourselves and leaving room

In Baltimore last week, one of the group of leaders I was working with confidently asserted ‘I’m a hugger’.  His reputation was clearly well known to hi...

Sifting: thoughts about diversity in Recruitment

Last week we were asked by a (female) client: ‘why is it that when I and two of my (female) colleagues sift CVs we lose most of the diversity we wanted ...

Personnel Today: Six ways to kickstart conversations about team stress at work

Rachael Forsberg shares six steps for workplaces properly discussing team stress, as a crucial first step in tackling it.

Personnel Today: BBC to ‘act immediately’ on workplace culture review

Ellie Herriot shares her insights with Personnel Today on how tackling everyday poor behaviour is key to preventing workplace scandals.